Handmade vs Designer Engagement Rings: What York Couples Prefer
Handmade or designer? Here’s how York couples are choosing their engagement rings — and what you should consider when deciding.
When couples visit my showroom, one of the most common questions I get is: should we go for a handmade ring or a designer one?
There’s no right or wrong — but there is a difference. And depending on your values, your timeline and your budget, one may suit you better than the other.
Here’s what York couples are choosing right now, and what I’d consider if you’re weighing up the options.
Handmade engagement rings in York are designed and crafted from scratch — often by a single jeweller, in their own workshop. Every detail is made to order: the setting, the finish, the gemstone.
When I create a handmade ring, I work directly with the client from first sketch to final polish. It’s personal, intentional, and truly one-of-one.
Designer engagement rings are often created by established brands and offered as part of a collection. They may still be beautifully made — but usually follow a set range of styles or materials.
For some couples, that’s ideal: you see it, you love it, you buy it. No changes needed.
In my experience, more couples in York are leaning towards custom engagement rings — especially for engagement.
Why? - They want something with personal meaning - They enjoy being part of the creative process - They value supporting local makers and independent York jewellers
That said, designer pieces still have their place — especially if time is tight or the style is already spot on.
|
Handmade Designer |
|
Uniqueness One-of-a-kind Collection-based |
|
Involvement Collaborative process Pre-designed |
|
Flexibility Fully customisable Limited customisation |
|
Timeframe 4–6 weeks typical Often available sooner |
|
Cost Often similar, depends on materials Brand value may increase pricing |
Learn more about our handmade engagement rings
If you’re looking for something truly personal — a ring that tells your story — handmade might be the way to go.
If you’ve already found a designer style that feels perfect, there’s no harm in following your heart.
I’d love to help you explore both options — and find the one that fits.
(DISCOVER)
